Four Chairs Verdict

Four Chairs Verdict forces one decision into a framed question - the real choice, the named options, the constraints - and refuses to convene on a vague one. Four chairs then run independently so they cannot anchor on each other: an Operator on execution cost, a Treasurer on capital and the worst realistic case, a Market chair on evidence of demand, and a Red Team that argues against and writes a pre-mortem. It maps where they genuinely disagree, then returns a recommendation, a confidence level, the strongest counter-argument, and the smallest reversible next step.